Skip to main content
Home

MotoMatters.com | Kropotkin Thinks

... that new tires might be a bigger deal than new engines

User Menu

  • Log in

Tools

  • Home
  • Subscriber Content
  • Round Ups
  • Features
    • Analysis
    • Interviews
    • Opinion
    • David Emmett's Blog
  • Photos
  • More
    • Search
    • Riders & Teams
    • Calendars
      • 2025 Provisional MotoGP Calendar
      • 2025 Provisional WorldSBK Calendar
    • Championship Standings
      • MotoGP Standings
      • Moto2 Standings
      • Moto3 Standings
      • MotoE Standings
      • WorldSBK Standings
      • WorldSSP Standings
    • Race Results
      • MotoGP Race Results
      • Moto2 Race Results
      • Moto3 Race Results
      • MotoE Race Results
      • WorldSBK Race Results
      • WorldSSP Race Results
    • News
      • MotoGP News
      • WorldSBK News
  • Subscribe!
    • More info about subscribing
  • Patreon
  • Forums
  • Contact

Breadcrumb

  • Home
  • Analysis and Background

Some autorenewing subscriptions have failed to automatically renew. If you find you can't read subscriber articles, or think this applies to you please read this.


Emilia-Romagna MotoGP Sunday Round Up: Momentum, Shmomentum, Fair Passes, And The Enigma Of Michelin's New Rear

By David Emmett | Tue, 24/Sep/2024 - 00:43

For the third race in a row, the Sunday MotoGP grand prix race has had us saying, "this is the moment the championship changed". Pecco Bagnaia left Austria with a lead of 5 points over Jorge Martin. Then he crashed out at Aragon after a collision with Alex Márquez, and Jorge Martin finished second behind Marc Márquez, giving Martin a comfortable-looking 23 point lead.

Was that the moment the momentum in the championship changed? Well, for seven days perhaps, as Jorge Martin entered the pits when rain was falling at the first Misano race, only to exit pit lane onto a dry track with wet tires. Bagnaia came second to (you guessed it) Marc Márquez, and cut the points gap to just 7 points.

Had the momentum changed for good this time, perhaps? You might think that, right until the moment that Bagnaia folded the front at Turn 8 on lap 21. Jorge Martin finished second to Enea Bastianini this time, controversially, and leads by 24 points again.

Momentum swings

I am starting to think that there is no such thing as momentum, that each grand prix is a separate, independent event. And that Jorge Martin and Pecco Bagnaia keep finding new ways to trip themselves up, despite being clearly the two best riders on the grid at the moment.

There are a host of factors at play here: the intense pressure that comes when a championship is being so closely fought. Martin and Bagnaia are on the same bike, fighting with the same tools, and - credit to Ducati - with pretty much the same support (though Jorge Martin will point to the fact that the factory team has an extra tire technician and extra data support). Martin and Bagnaia are pushing one another to extraordinarily high levels, trying to find the smallest advantage over the other. A grab bag of hard and fast rivals, prime among them Marc Márquez and Enea Bastianini. And above all, the fact that as riders, teams, and factories master more and more aspects of MotoGP, the importance of even the smallest detail is magnified out of proportion.

Then there's the stuff that riders just don't have within their own control. At the Emilia-Romagna round, both Martin and Bagnaia could point to outside factors as the source of their woes. Those outside factors proved a bitter pill to swallow for the two championship rivals, but helped make for a fascinating, and in the final few laps, thrilling MotoGP race.

The first topic that needs to be addressed is the way Enea Bastianini snatched victory from Jorge Martin. Martin had disposed of Bastianini's Ducati Lenovo teammate early in the race (much more about that later), and was in control of the first half of the race, though his lead over the factory Ducati rider was continually under a second.

On lap 17, Martin's pace slackened a little - only by a tenth or so, while Bastianini pushed on for his second fastest lap, taking three tenths out of the Pramac Ducati rider and closing the gap to just over four tenths of a second. From there, Bastianini slowly chipped away at Martin's lead, a few hundredths at a time, snapping at the Spaniard's heels ever more menacingly.

It was clear that Bastianini was faster than Martin in the first sector and in the last sector. Martin reigned supreme in the third sector, meaning the gap was too big entering the last sector for Bastianini to launch an attack there. "In sector 3, from the exit of Turn 10, he was the strongest," Bastianini said. "I don't know why, but at the end of the long straight, I was always 0.2, 0.3 behind." So the first sector was Bastianini's only chance. "It was the only opportunity to try to win the race."

Last chance

So Bastianini chose to attack at Turn 4. Martin braked at the limit on the entry to the corner, the rear of his Pramac Ducati fishtailing, and that gave Bastianini a glimpse of daylight. Enough to dive underneath and try to pass. Bastianini got his nose in front of the Pramac Ducati just as Martin started to turn into the corner. The two touched, Martin was forced wide, and Bastianini glanced back and ran all the way out to the edge of the track, and put his wheels outside the kerbs.

Bastianini lost six tenths in the clash, but Martin lost nearly two seconds. It was enough to secure victory or the Italian, ensuring that Ducati's 100th premier class victory went to the factory team, and saving their blushes.

To celebrate that occasion, Ducati sent Michele Pirro up to collect the team trophy. It was well-deserved recognition for the Herculean task Pirro has been charged with over the years. As Ducati's main test rider since 2013, he has helped develop the Desmosedici from a hapless backmarker to the machine that is crushing the life out of its competitors. Pirro is one of the key building blocks of Ducati's success, but his role is often overlooked.

Fair vs legal

Was Bastianini's pass fair? And was it legal? The FIM Stewards report at the end of Sunday makes no mention of even investigating it, meaning Race Direction and the Stewards will have not thought it worthy of reviewing. Unsurprisingly, Bastianini and Martin had very different views of the pass.

14
2024
MotoGP
Misano, Italy
Ducati
Enea Bastianini
Francesco Bagnaia
Jorge Martin
CormacGP
  • Log in or register to post comments
↑Back to top

Comments

I just can't imagine...

B.Mac
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

... how wonderful Jorge Martin would feel running the No.1 plate on an Aprilia next year.  I really hope it happens.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to I just can't imagine... by B.Mac

It would be a pretty tasty…

guy smiley
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

It would be a pretty tasty outcome. I just hope Aprilia can bring the little extra performance (and reliability) they need so Jorge can still be competitive at the leading edge next year. Riding around in 6th the #1 plate probably wouldn't be much consolation. 

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to It would be a pretty tasty… by guy smiley

Yes...

B.Mac
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

... that's a very good point Guy,

  • Log in or register to post comments

Fantastic article David

slowgeek
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Keep up the good work and I shall be forced to subscribe for another year

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Fantastic article David by slowgeek

Thank you!

David Emmett
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Thank you!

  • Log in or register to post comments

Ducati are…

Rusty Trumpet
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

…desperate to prevent that from happening. Two irrelevant questions: firstly can Marshall’s keep broken bits from crashed bikes or do they have to go back to the team (Acosta’s broken wing) and secondly, what’s with the advertising hoardings for Termas Del Rio Hondo? I don’ t believe that Argentina’s economic situation has improved since last year’s cancellation?

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Ducati are… by Rusty Trumpet

Arg...

Jerry Neal
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

We wondered the exact same thing!

Don't cry for Termas del Argentina, the truth is we never loved you. Too far to get to with no good lodging, you tried our patience, please keep your distance...

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Arg... by Jerry Neal

Nice..

Rusty Trumpet
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

…one!

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Arg... by Jerry Neal

Ha, very good

Moto Mondo
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

but maybe the Argentinian GP is actually coming back next year? And India is out (again)?

https://www.autosport.com/motogp/news/indian-gp-fading-out-of-2025-motogp-calendar/10657621/

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Ducati are… by Rusty Trumpet

Broken bits

stefank
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

At Phillip Island we're told (sternly) that all the broken bits must go back with the bikes. No souvenirs.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Broken bits by stefank

Your visitation rights to my…

D999
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Your visitation rights to my pool room have now been revoked.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Ducati are… by Rusty Trumpet

It probably depends on how…

dewang
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

It probably depends on how broken the bits are. I was at Donington for WSBK and we got a fairing piece as well as a little winglet from Sam Lowes' Ducati. The bike was taken behind and into the recovery truck pretty sharpish. We only went and picked up the pieces from the gravel after the end of the session so there was no question of them going back with the bike.

  • Log in or register to post comments

Track Limits

D999
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

I popped this in the race thread, but I'll pop it in here now that the conversation has shifted over here.

Why was Martin not warned for this early track limits infringement? - (51:30 of main video pass feed) -  https://imgur.com/a/FwfEDka

For all the talk of track limits at the end, this was plain as day on the official feed.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Track Limits by D999

He did get a track limits…

David Emmett
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

He did get a track limits warning for that. The official results PDF file has all of the warnings and other events.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Track Limits by D999

I noticed this too and…

bgurba
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

I noticed this too and rewound that part of the race a few times to see if I was mistaken. It look the officials about 10 laps to put up the track limits warning which seems to be way too long....

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to I noticed this too and… by bgurba

They get a warning after…

WaveyD1974
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

They get a warning after exceeding track limits 3 times and a long lap after 5. That's Sunday. Sprint race is 2 and 3.

  • Log in or register to post comments

2005 or 2006

Apical
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Back when  Julián Simón was racing a KTM 125 a Marshall got a souvenir. J.S. crashed at Miller corner Philip Island 2005 or 6. Known as Honda corner at the time.

A colleague of mine was marshalling there. I was given a piece of carbon fibre nose cone with orange paint on it. Still around somewhere.

I've picked up some interesting bits and pieces on track walks over the years. Toe & knee sliders. Nuts, bolts and washers. Logos & badges.

 

 

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to 2005 or 2006 by Apical

Hi Steve

Rusty Trumpet
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

I thought that Acosta’s cleanly broken off wing would have been a nice pickup.

  • Log in or register to post comments

I can't 100% disagree with…

Taffmeister
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

I can't 100% disagree with the idea of evidence based rules that nobody can argue about.  Enea left the track, that's evidence so drop a place.  Even if he crosses the line ahead he would just simply be dropped to second.  

We just need clear rules but I do like the idea that if a rider stays on there is no case.  

"But there are scenarios imaginable where crashing might be the smart thing to do to elicit a penalty."
No Dave, you have and never will be given points for being on your arse!  that is - unless they change the rules.  

IT'S ALL IN THE RULES.  get 'em right we all undestand.  Get 'em wrong and we just argue and bicker.  

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to I can't 100% disagree with… by Taffmeister

It's already happened in…

WaveyD1974
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

It's already happened in 2015. No, not a spill, not that one. Assen, without the contact Rossi cut the chicane. With contact, he won the race.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to I can't 100% disagree with… by Taffmeister

Track limits

scottyreg
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Enea didn’t transgress track limits though. You’re saying you want hard and fast rules, but unless there is a sensor there like there is with the green areas, you can’t judge the limits. If it’s really close it just comes down to one guy’s opinion.

As for crashing scenarios: imagine in the last race Jorge makes a similar move on Enea. Enea could crash to elicit a penalty for Martin, helping Pecco win the title. Far-fetched maybe but not impossible.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to I can't 100% disagree with… by Taffmeister

Enforce the rules

Nealio
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Taffmiester, i agree that the rules are the basis for a competition. Enea clearly had his tires on blue asphalt and the stewards shamefully didn't enforce the rules. Italian race, Italian rider and Italian Motorcycle, Hum.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Enforce the rules by Nealio

Ugh

CTK
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

They didnt penalize him because he didnt gain any time from going off. If you're going to accuse the stewards of something at least understand the rules you claim they broke.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Enforce the rules by Nealio

Bogus

Seven4nineR
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Just plain incorrect. You state yourself “blue paint”: the rules do NOT  mandate penalties for riding on blue paint. There was no rule to enforce.

To butcher an old saying: Enea left Martin just enough room to come second. 

Sure, Enea is making a tough move, but Martin also loses the front momentarily when turning in, which makes everything worse. But why turn in on Enea who has position?

Martin would have heard Enea coming, and Enea had  to massively compromise his corner to make the Marquez-like move, which was just begging for a Dovi-style undercut…but instead he turns in. It’s understandable, but it’s not smart.

Kudos to Enea for going for it.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Bogus by Seven4nineR

Sure, Enea is making a tough…

Taffmeister
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

From 749R
Sure, Enea is making a tough move, but Martin also loses the front momentarily when turning in, which makes everything worse. But why turn in on Enea who has position?

Martin would have heard Enea coming, and Enea had  to massively compromise his corner to make the Marquez-like move, which was just begging for a Dovi-style undercut…but instead he turns in. It’s understandable, but it’s not smart.
Kudos to Enea for going for it.

He didn't know he was coming 749 and if he did then he knew he was coming for the previous 37 corners. The noise of the bike behind doesn't get louder till it has happened.  You live with the constant knowledge that it's coming but the difference between following and coming up beside is all over in less than half a second.  

Moving On. 
Two comments on the incident.  Enea come in vertically and on the brakes to maximise the braking force. This worked.  

Most people think you fall into a corner, infact you counter-steer so Enea in order to lean over needs his wheels under Jorge's right footrest but can't put them there and so he now DOES have to fall over and that takes longer than counter-steering.  

You have the least trail under full braking therefore can't counter-steer and can only fall over at low speeds.  Most people have braked stupidly hard and only flopped over at the end of it.  

So, the fact is Enea was upright and "ushering" (in a nice way) Jorge off the track with himself trying to lay down his own bike ASAP. Jorge was 'stood up'!  BTW, Jorge was only half as pissed as he would have been if 3 other riders had been backing it in behind them both!  

The good news is that this close vertical contact on Jorge, kept Jorge on his bike.  As 749R says;

"Enea left Martin just enough room to come second".  

At least Enea got right up next to him and didn't do an Alex Marquez.  

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Sure, Enea is making a tough… by Taffmeister

Countersteering

Seven4nineR
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Absolutely true. Point taken, thanks.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to I can't 100% disagree with… by Taffmeister

the track ends at the white…

janbros
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

the track ends at the white line, not where there is no more asphalt.

the easy solution is to paint the entire edges of the track with green paint

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to the track ends at the white… by janbros

They did. They then had a…

WaveyD1974
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

They did. They then had a new idea and painted some blue for a reason.

  • Log in or register to post comments

MMs comment of; 'leave the…

Taffmeister
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

MMs comment of; 'leave the track' you lose a place; are they MMs rules?

Clearly Scottyreg we are of different generations; 
"If it’s really close it just comes down to one guy’s opinion".  The rules right now are enforced by a 'guy's opinion'. Even watching VR in footie - they still can't agree!  All I've ever known is 'a guy's opinion' until very recently and to be honest, it was easier.  It's the idea that you can bitch, argue and get a change in the result that gets ya!.  

By the way, I've been heavily involved in refereeing RU over the years; tip, attach rules to the ground, its clearer. That is why they argue about tyres on the green paint and not elbows over it.  

  • Log in or register to post comments

excellent summary

ellcap
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

this is why I subscribe each year. all of the details I miss are often caught in these reports. 

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to excellent summary by ellcap

Thank you!

David Emmett
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Thank you!

  • Log in or register to post comments

After watching the race…

spongedaddy
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

After watching the race again from Bastianini's onboard, I would have been bummed if the race had been decided by a penalty. Those guys were engaged in a real dogfight. Bastianini seemed to have more speed the last few laps. He just had to find a way past. Martin was pulling some good moves to keep him at bay. Excellent race.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to After watching the race… by spongedaddy

Agreed

brettak
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

I want to see Martin win the championship, he doesn't dummyspit, deals with his errors matter of factly, doesn't seem to repeat them [much] and he's FAST.

But, he did run a little wide after stepping out the rear, leaving  Bestia a gap. And Enea only ran wide when he was looking at Jorge, so no problem.

And if there's no green, there's no green, so likewise, fair enough.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to Agreed by brettak

And Martin's riding style,…

Motoshrink
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

And Martin's riding style, isn't he great to watch chuck a bike around brett? He is physically STRONG, and wrangles the beast. Wilder than most, and enthusiastic. He belongs in an old Western movie made in Italy. Pecco is the town Dr with spectacles, that rides and shoots w the best of them. The old Sheriff is Marc, dealing with slightly less fire power. I digress yet again. Hoping Martin wins it too, but runs his reg # in Black next yr. It will be a tough move to the 2nd or 3rd pack, wishing he and Aprilia all the best.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to And Martin's riding style,… by Motoshrink

Nah, he has to run #1 if he…

db
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Nah, he has to run #1 if he wins. It would be outrageous for it to be on an aprilia I love it.

  • Log in or register to post comments

I love a hung jury

lotsofchops
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

I do always really like when rider opinions are so split. I give a lot of weight to the musings of those doing the job day in day out. As an amateur trackday enthusiast, I've had a glimpse of how fast everything happens out there, and these guys are doing it at speeds I can't hope to attain. For me, it was a racing move considering it's last lap and for the win; context absolutely matters and race direction can pretend to be objective but they aren't. 

  • Log in or register to post comments

"...the need to do things such as travel, eat, and sleep..."

isoia
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

David - How about sharing how you manage these vitals (in addition to where and when) while doing what you do to bring us MUCH closer to the action; maybe an off-season post?  What are accommodations like (and do journalists get "closer" accommodations, etc?) Pre-race buffet for journalists (!) or do you have to compete with fans for sustenance? When you ride to a race, is there designated parking for journalists (broadcasters, track workers, etc.?) And...do you have access to cool swag the rest of us will only see on video broadcasts!? 

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to "...the need to do things such as travel, eat, and sleep..." by isoia

This is a really good idea…

David Emmett
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

This is a really good idea. I will do something like this in December.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to This is a really good idea… by David Emmett

+2

Morgs
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

+2

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to "...the need to do things such as travel, eat, and sleep..." by isoia

+1

spongedaddy
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

+1

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to +1 by spongedaddy

+1

B.Mac
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

here too... great idea Isoia.

  • Log in or register to post comments

In reply to "...the need to do things such as travel, eat, and sleep..." by isoia

What he said...

Rob@Orewa_NZ
Site Supporter
5 months 3 weeks ago
Permalink

Now we're really squeezing the stone for the last drop of blood, but if you can do it, David, that would be a great addition to the down season. Thanks for all the work you do for those of us who will never be able to attend a race weekend in person.

  • Log in or register to post comments

Donate to the Aspar Team's fund to provide aid to everyone affected by the devastating floods in Valencia.


Find MotoMatters on Bluesky and Mastodon

Support Simon Crafar's Riders for Dogs charity, and help rescued dogs find a better home.

Buy Neil Spalding's essential guide to the technology of MotoGP bikes, MotoGP Technology.

Recent comments

  • Marc has a plan joeR6 1 hour 24 minutes ago
  • No Zarco love ? Matonge 1 hour 50 minutes ago
  • So true motomann 3 hours 23 minutes ago
  • Not falling cause he doesn’t need to find the limit  Gerrycollins 4 hours 52 minutes ago
  • At what age? Apical 5 hours 23 minutes ago

All content copyright of MotoMatters.com unless otherwise stated. MotoGP is a trademark of Dorna Sports s.l. and MotoMatters.com is not associated with it.

Site hosted by